CMJ
Weekly, April 6, 1998
"On
the strength of its first full-length, Charcoal,
Champaign, Illinoiss
Sarge burst upon the national indie scene at the end of
1996. Fans were charmed by the intelligent lyrics and great
pop songs of vocalist Elizabeth Elmore. In fact, just months
into its existence, the young band was compared to Sleater-Kinney,
Scrawl, and even Throwing Muses. Sarge has since matured,
though, distancing itself from grrrl rock and evolving
into a straight-up pop band in the process. For The
Glass Intact, Elmore and bassist sidekick Rachel Switzky
have brought in new drummer Chad Romanski and added second
guitarist Pat Cramer. The new additions trigger a notable
jump in the bands musicianship, and it maintains
a guileless, sympathetic light touch that stays out of
the way of Elmores pretty songs but still rocks on
cuts when its needed." Tad Hendrickson
Salon
Magazine, March 20, 1998
"
They
draw on the tunefulness of pop, the energy of punk and
something shared
by artists as disparate and connected as Nirvana or Neil
Young
Everything
about The
Glass Intact from the production by the band
and Matt Alison to the freedom and discipline in the
playing of Elmore and new guitarist Pat Cramer, bassist
Rachel Switzky and drummer Chad Romanski sharpens,
deepens and expands the sound and the meanings of Sarges
1996 Charcoal
The Glass Intact offers
the exhilaration of hearing a young band find its voice
and the satisfaction of feeling youre being talked
to honestly, directly, as an adult, free to join the conversation." Charles
Taylor
Alternative
Press, September 1997
"Sarges Elizabeth
Elmore wanted to be in a band so badly, she would leave
clubs in her college town of Champaign, Illinois, sobbing. I
didnt think I could play guitar well enough, she
admits. I didnt know if anybody would like
the songs I wrote. Yet none of that insecurity surfaces
in Elmores songs, which speaks so honestly and directly
its hard to believe she could be afraid of anything.
Seething with passion, frustration,
bitterness, and vulnerability, the songs on Charcoal (Mud
Records) might have stayed in Elmores notebook forever
if Rachel Switzky hadnt returned to Champaign for
her masters degree, started playing bass with Elmore
and handed their tape to her next-door neighbor, Parasol
Records Geoff Merritt.
Now my life is pretty
good, says Elmore. Im doing everything
I ever wanted to do. Whats left to write about? I
tried to write this really nice song about my boyfriend,
all la-la-la and Im in love. It turned
out mean. It just doesnt suit me to write happy songs." David
Daley
Art
Forum
"Women speak the harsh,
desperate language of Denis Johnsons Jesus Son in
the songs of this Illinois punk trio (I walked into
the bar where you hung out/24 and I still hadnt figured
it out/Eight months pregnant and sick with all these lies)
but theres a will to speak a more commonplace language
in Elizabeth Elmores singing and guitar playing.
Theres as much Van Halen in her sound as Gang of
Four." Greil Marcus
CMJ
Music Monthly, February 1997
"Punk rock groups led by
female singer-songwriters are popping up more frequently
these days, but where Sarge fits into that fray isnt
really clear, as Charcoal really has more surprises
than cliches. Sarge is from Champaign, IL; by all current
standards of measurement, its definitely a Champaign
band, or more accurately, a really good meshing of
certain regional musical ideologies: like bassist Rachel
Switzkys old band Corndolly, the band is predominantly
woman-based, and the songwriting is thoroughly solid. And,
like many other Champaign bands, Sarge sincerely rocks. Dear
Josie, Love Robyn is pure Buzzcocks, and the whole
record (up until the last few softer-but-not-soft tracks)
is totally punk rockunderneath Elizabeth Elmores
sometimes difficult to reconcile vocals. Elmores
singing, a little reminiscent of Velocity Girls Sarah
Shannon, is deceptively sweet, wrapped around nine songs
which are almost angrylashing out at deception, betrayal,
and physical abuse. I Dont is a reminder
that people should pianos into rock songs way more than
they do. Which is not to say Sarge is trying to cover huge
amounts of groundits notbut its
doing what it does with quite a lot of depth, and for that
matter, first-rate songs." Liz Clayton
Puncture
"With all the sped-up perkiness
of the Fastbacks and all the careless tralala of Heavenly,
the three upstanding Illinoisans comprising Sarge careen
up and make a pretty, purgative noise. Vocalist/main songwriter
Elizabeth Elmore, solo or harmonizing with herself, sings
songs about ugly breakups, dysfunctional families, bloodthirsty
retribution, and worsemaking it all sound nice as
pie while guitar, bass, and drums jangle plenty behind
her
The
suspicion that Sarges
pert nonchalance operates as cheap irony, or that it signifies
some deficit of emotion, gets allayed in the stark, slower Another
Gear Uncaught, a chilling before-and-after account
of a suicide attempt conveyed through a monologue addressed
to an unseen person, or maybe to the narrators alter
ego.
Songs
about suicide are bound to be too maudlin to bear, but
Elmore flirts, threatens,
rages, and despairs in such subtle turns that the song
survives to haunt the listener. When the cold meaning sinks
in, the prettiness fades; but Sarge love to tease with
these two sides to their music; and lucky you, you dont
have to choose." Sara Manaugh
Chickfactor, Issue #10
"My
friend and I were arguing a few weeks ago whether Bikini
Kill or Team Dresch would
be the band that would be the most historically important
ten years from now. He said Bikini Kill because they were
the ones that inspired so many girls to start their own
bands. I said Team Dresch because they will be the ones
who inspired the good ones. Sarges first album
is an initial point of evidence for my side. Its
clearly the product of a boy-crazy girl listening to Personal
Best about a million times. Its also funny and
angry and tuneful and fast and instrumentally awesome and
so on-the-mark it makes me smile every time. And theyre
only going to get better the aforementioned girl
is 20 years old. Yay." -- Clarissa